Source Details

{
    "source_type": "extension",
    "content_hash": "c7244b579f8567a661c733a304b58ae1857f667807dd4905f077bdd89b8adacf",
    "submitted_via": "chrome_extension",
    "extension_version": "1.0.18",
    "original_url": "https:\/\/www.nytimes.com\/2026\/02\/16\/nyregion\/columbia-epstein-dental-shuliak.html?campaign_id=9&emc=edit_nn_20260217&instance_id=171200&nl=the-morning&regi_id=122976029&segment_id=215386&user_id=b25c5730c89e0c73f75709d8f1254337",
    "parsed_content": "The Epstein FilesLatest ReleaseConspiracy Theories FlourishFiles Include VideosLawmakers Question BondiPowerful Men in FilesReferences to TrumpAdvertisementSKIP ADVERTISEMENTSupported bySKIP ADVERTISEMENTColumbia Punishes 2 Who Helped Epstein\u2019s Girlfriend Enter Dental CollegeThe release of documents tied to Jeffrey Epstein has sent ripples through the worlds of business, politics and academia, including at Columbia, where he helped his girlfriend gain entry.Listen to this article \u00b7 5:47 min Learn moreShare full articleColumbia University said it will be donating money to nonprofits that work with survivors of sexual abuse after it disclosed that Jeffrey Epstein helped his girlfriend bypass admission standards.Credit...Justice DepartmentBy Ed ShanahanFeb. 16, 2026Columbia University has punished two people affiliated with its dental college after documents released by the Justice Department revealed that they had bypassed the normal process to help Jeffrey Epstein\u2019s girlfriend gain admission.The actions taken against the two people, Dr. Thomas Magnani and Dr. Letty Moss-Salentijn, add to the fallout rippling through the worlds of academia, business, politics and beyond with the release of millions of pages of files related to Mr. Epstein.The documents shed light on communications between Mr. Epstein and College of Dental Medicine representatives that Columbia officials knew about as of 2019, the university said in a statement on Friday.As a result, Columbia said it was cutting all ties to Dr. Magnani and stripping Dr. Moss-Salentijn of her administrative duties at the dental college, where she remains a tenured faculty member. Several other people implicated in the episode had already ended their affiliations with the school, the statement said.AdvertisementSKIP ADVERTISEMENTDr. Magnani and Dr. Moss-Salentijn did not immediately respond to requests for comment.The university also said it had identified $210,000 in donations from \u201centities related to\u201d Mr. Epstein, and would be donating that amount, split between two New York nonprofit organizations that support survivors of sexual abuse and human trafficking.\u201cIn short,\u201d the university said, \u201ca student was admitted to the dental school through an irregular process, coinciding with fund-raising solicitations by former academic and alumni leadership of the school.\u201dAlthough not named in the statement, the student in question was Karyna Shuliak, the last person Mr. Epstein spoke to by phone before his death by suicide in a Manhattan prison cell in 2019 while facing federal sex-trafficking charges. He paid for Ms. Shuliak\u2019s dental school tuition and other courses. In his will, he left her $100 million.Ms. Shuliak graduated from the dental college in 2015. She is now 36 and believed to be living in New York. A lawyer who has represented her, Maurice H. Sercarz, did not immediately respond to a request for comment. AdvertisementSKIP ADVERTISEMENTMs. Shuliak was 22 when her initial application to the dental college was rejected in 2012. After Mr. Epstein, who had pleaded guilty to soliciting a minor for prostitution in Florida four years earlier, said he was considering a donation to the school, several influential people there moved to ensure she got in.The dean of the dental college contacted the medical school in Ms. Shuliak\u2019s native Belarus, where she had nearly finished her dental studies, to ask for her records. The adult dentistry chair sent Ms. Shuliak study guides and an outline for Columbia\u2019s entrance exam. After Ms. Shuliak\u2019s admission, Dr. Moss-Salentijn, the vice dean for academic affairs at the time, helped develop a personalized plan of study for Ms. Shuliak because she had joined Columbia later than usual for a dental transfer student.Mr. Epstein subsequently gave $100,000 to a public health project run by the dean of the dental college at the time, Dr. Ira B. Lamster, and $50,000 to the dental school\u2019s annual fund in Ms. Shuliak\u2019s honor, the Justice Department documents show.Dr. Magnani, Mr. Epstein\u2019s dentist, was the point person for the effort to secure Ms. Shuliak\u2019s admission, arranging a tour of the college and helping to revive her application, the Justice Department documents show. On the eve of her entrance exam, he resisted when Mr. Epstein suggested delaying the test a week so that he could visit the college first.\u201cHe says not to rock the boat,\u201d Mr. Epstein\u2019s assistant, Lesley Groff, told her boss in an April 2012 email, referring to a call she had just had with Dr. Magnani.AdvertisementSKIP ADVERTISEMENT\u201cShe is with the most powerful people there who are already meeting halfway and moving things around to accommodate her,\u201d Ms. Groff told Mr. Epstein.Later, in January 2018, Dr. Magnani encouraged Mr. Epstein to donate to the dental college, the Justice Department files show. He wrote to Mr. Epstein that he had just had dinner with the school\u2019s new dean and Dr. Moss-Salentijn, who Dr. Magnani said \u201cwas Karyna\u2019s mentor and did the most to help her get in and finish up dental school.\u201dDr. Magnani said that it would be appreciated if Mr. Epstein would donate $450,000 to a high-tech dental training initiative that Dr. Moss-Salentijn was involved with, the files show. Months later, Dr. Moss-Salentijn sent along a funding proposal, and a dinner with Mr. Epstein was planned, the files show. The donation was never made, Columbia said. (Campus Reform, a conservative news site, first reported the exchange.)The university said in its statement that Dr. Magnani, a 1980 graduate of the college, had not taught there since 2017 and had previously stepped down from the college\u2019s board of advisers. Because of the revelations in the Justice Department files, the university said it had removed him from the admissions review committee and his volunteer leadership roles, including the presidency of an organization for major donors to the college.Dr. Magnani\u2019s voluntary faculty appointment and an affiliation agreement with his private dental practice had also been terminated, the university said. On Monday, the website for his practice continued to list him as an assistant clinical professor at the Columbia dental school and a member of the admissions committee.Sharon Otterman contributed reporting.Ed Shanahan is a rewrite reporter and editor covering breaking news and general assignments on the Metro desk.A version of this article appears in print on Feb. 17, 2026, Section A, Page 12 of the New York edition with the headline: Columbia Punishes 2 Who Helped Epstein\u2019s Girlfriend Enter Dental College. Order Reprints | Today\u2019s Paper | SubscribeSee more on: U.S. Justice Department, Jeffrey EpsteinShare full articleRelated ContentAdvertisementSKIP ADVERTISEMENT",
    "ai_headline": "Columbia Punishes 2 Who Helped Epstein\u2019s Girlfriend Enter Dental College",
    "ai_simplified_title": "Columbia University Punishes Officials Over Epstein Girlfriend Admission",
    "ai_excerpt": "Columbia University disciplined two individuals affiliated with its dental college after documents revealed they helped Jeffrey Epstein's girlfriend gain admission. The university is also donating funds related to Epstein to support survivors of sexual abuse. The article details the actions taken and the individuals involved.",
    "ai_subject_tags": [
        "Jeffrey Epstein",
        "Columbia University",
        "Sexual Abuse",
        "Dental College",
        "Karyna Shuliak",
        "Admissions Scandal"
    ],
    "ai_context_type": "News",
    "ai_context_details": {
        "tone": "informative",
        "perspective": "neutral",
        "audience": "general",
        "credibility_indicators": [
            "expert_quotes",
            "data_cited",
            "official statements"
        ]
    },
    "ai_source_vector": [
        -0.016151398,
        -0.013566691,
        -0.00200397,
        -0.065192245,
        0.006720138,
        0.0032661674,
        0.0033699642,
        0.010364185,
        0.018574182,
        0.016555721,
        -0.0069285394,
        -0.0012585798,
        0.006888764,
        -0.02613362,
        0.10448601,
        0.02245701,
        0.014640186,
        0.02761707,
        0.028620558,
        0.0017380493,
        -0.014401924,
        -0.016891947,
        -0.029661963,
        -0.02760099,
        0.02720991,
        -0.025003858,
        0.01993095,
        -0.011629573,
        0.01999951,
        0.026592597,
        -0.022253534,
        0.000570534,
        -0.0015375224,
        0.0014119917,
        0.0308968,
        0.028122356,
        0.011002361,
        -0.015371704,
        0.013377004,
        -0.005100342,
        0.00140695,
        0.04657004,
        -0.006532606,
        0.028577551,
        0.04879704,
        -0.0009957892,
        0.0068729273,
        -0.021355676,
        -0.012825637,
        0.024828928,
        -0.0015785096,
        0.00893641,
        -0.018022528,
        -0.16683233,
        -0.030268602,
        -0.018032571,
        -0.0139610665,
        -0.00075856264,
        0.00052161794,
        -0.0058182436,
        0.002323557,
        0.021964755,
        -0.029859329,
        -0.035205793,
        -0.007257039,
        -0.047896743,
        -0.0034926103,
        -8.447281e-5,
        -0.035943545,
        0.012141507,
        -0.0153483255,
        0.0018271812,
        -0.026676646,
        -0.015090007,
        -0.010826629,
        -0.01525899,
        0.013926456,
        0.020176176,
        -0.012865597,
        -0.0042223884,
        -0.024529139,
        -0.021787796,
        -0.020414166,
        0.0017716676,
        0.007828558,
        -0.022209305,
        -0.021845482,
        -0.03299985,
        0.01840298,
        -0.009608482,
        -0.026511578,
        -0.007885523,
        0.021466635,
        -0.031697158,
        -0.0096061975,
        0.004688688,
        0.011831731,
        0.017536664,
        0.034633048,
        -0.0017698009,
        -0.020556364,
        0.00023986024,
        -0.03853881,
        -0.026328957,
        0.004403369,
        -0.01928882,
        -0.016549464,
        0.009820096,
        0.008255528,
        0.019084724,
        0.0012811149,
        -0.015715286,
        -0.010207343,
        -0.007780659,
        0.008594633,
        -0.14175095,
        0.005652292,
        -0.0071442006,
        -0.013797895,
        -0.04317793,
        0.008988784,
        -0.01666356,
        0.02676891,
        -0.013798107,
        -0.01116219,
        -0.0013631633,
        0.0134918615,
        0.010093967,
        -0.014423625,
        0.0057054986,
        -0.038089264,
        -0.0062711174,
        0.01123033,
        -0.009703593,
        0.010372802,
        0.010110789,
        0.010066394,
        0.00024795128,
        0.003644397,
        -0.016934995,
        -0.009701328,
        0.02019726,
        0.015915053,
        0.041811634,
        0.0024363473,
        -0.0007501678,
        0.020733658,
        0.010174189,
        -0.0020747783,
        -0.009159885,
        -0.002392463,
        -0.014145086,
        0.01837239,
        -0.018534362,
        0.035361413,
        -0.023049582,
        -0.039097913,
        -0.022178274,
        -0.0021260818,
        0.03172634,
        -0.001735088,
        0.014829391,
        0.013576618,
        0.025549114,
        0.021296056,
        0.00909366,
        0.005174727,
        0.016683962,
        -0.0014347242,
        0.0042268788,
        -0.023560641,
        0.009407729,
        0.0058678305,
        0.010381583,
        -0.04709604,
        -0.002848156,
        0.010551827,
        0.008475235,
        0.004661181,
        0.0372727,
        4.736352e-5,
        0.014198416,
        0.006547493,
        0.003499334,
        0.01802788,
        0.003324502,
        -0.0091383755,
        -0.02854204,
        0.0109035615,
        -0.00068793894,
        -0.038363658,
        -0.020384308,
        0.0061517395,
        -0.011504639,
        0.0050978684,
        0.0012659824,
        -0.011903849,
        0.0105569055,
        -0.020065121,
        0.021423727,
        -0.0010083686,
        0.0013046798,
        0.0041093407,
        -0.0030971295,
        0.012852508,
        0.00303721,
        -0.010010462,
        -0.031047273,
        -0.0044216537,
        0.006507007,
        0.014411284,
        0.0025278404,
        -0.0040664603,
        0.0030513941,
        0.024750065,
        0.0004442118,
        -0.0005388736,
        -0.018097494,
        -0.015504948,
        -0.043158058,
        -0.0017681281,
        -0.008697063,
        0.005561041,
        -0.005956535,
        -0.00777412,
        0.0031536445,
        0.036520004,
        0.0019908904,
        0.0016203381,
        -0.001859229,
        0.012711267,
        0.019278122,
        -0.022949371,
        -0.01361209,
        0.009519481,
        -0.042014353,
        0.0041581616,
        -0.02475342,
        0.006676172,
        -0.0055573555,
        -0.0038696686,
        0.0027340301,
        0.0079365615,
        -0.022235911,
        0.009694601,
        2.843728e-5,
        -0.012747637,
        -0.012396177,
        -0.022891173,
        -0.031437896,
        0.00878243,
        0.012705587,
        0.022184508,
        -0.019223128,
        -0.010163835,
        0.008606731,
        -0.020910284,
        0.0075970395,
        0.0026021034,
        0.005120912,
        -0.008410717,
        -0.013701327,
        -0.018133849,
        0.0007808129,
        0.031485546,
        0.0133137,
        0.03109948,
        0.0070530046,
        -0.010704214,
        -0.010819563,
        -0.0069811507,
        -0.0050101774,
        -0.0009414095,
        -0.0018545213,
        0.013118804,
        0.021453552,
        -0.087086126,
        -0.0003100983,
        -0.008727982,
        0.010088636,
        0.022963857,
        0.029059777,
        -0.008949408,
        0.03224434,
        -0.003151383,
        -0.002795822,
        -0.0018069544,
        0.014496472,
        0.012134996,
        0.0115510635,
        0.036779564,
        -0.003027603,
        -0.0075991764,
        -0.022498274,
        0.01436626,
        -0.022512823,
        0.014353473,
        -0.007205206,
        -0.015255047,
        -0.02288201,
        0.0071657198,
        0.03671841,
        0.011987002,
        0.0578845,
        0.005986975,
        -0.016066749,
        0.0100439945,
        -0.016439194,
        -7.973083e-5,
        0.0025256465,
        -0.0112059675,
        0.0035355822,
        -0.00057571626,
        -0.012757069,
        0.0136267105,
        -0.024030678,
        0.0042247744,
        0.009001191,
        -0.012324756,
        -0.012709115,
        -0.027377583,
        0.0032696554,
        -0.006037111,
        -0.0061313384,
        -0.0064614867,
        -0.013062324,
        -0.016307876,
        0.012059863,
        0.027987277,
        0.022451261,
        -0.031785943,
        0.007962598,
        0.013599272,
        0.016744902,
        -0.007925065,
        0.011425551,
        0.0061641647,
        -0.02138288,
        0.021685513,
        0.01713656,
        -0.0014865999,
        -0.0026025986,
        -0.012269637,
        -0.023922397,
        -0.004960164,
        0.018329822,
        -0.0035838154,
        0.002274178,
        -0.023862869,
        -0.0065911524,
        -0.011542445,
        0.008966225,
        0.022495745,
        0.0029305122,
        -0.02476318,
        0.033817902,
        0.004505484,
        0.010433915,
        -0.01583946,
        -0.0010168062,
        0.010996155,
        0.0044698264,
        0.012647726,
        -0.011787586,
        -0.005469469,
        -0.023064438,
        -0.00067236443,
        0.0071410444,
        -0.022460567,
        0.010182763,
        -0.012283979,
        0.018537551,
        -0.005202519,
        0.0149727985,
        -0.0017176664,
        0.021722117,
        0.0029621003,
        -0.012548371,
        -0.019083729,
        -0.0041438653,
        -0.0038890145,
        0.007851295,
        -0.007940549,
        -0.021847077,
        0.0141213965,
        0.031365562,
        0.006296817,
        -0.009433574,
        -0.0024727318,
        0.028959999,
        0.01058532,
        0.02307707,
        -0.007321382,
        -0.004948411,
        0.014787504,
        0.022972751,
        0.025136052,
        -0.00051580847,
        0.013346712,
        0.036688175,
        0.011003272,
        0.039307807,
        0.0077753766,
        0.023028363,
        0.017201602,
        0.02981605,
        0.030909153,
        -0.0047243265,
        -0.01424552,
        -0.022272097,
        -0.0006602902,
        -0.026095837,
        0.0052067763,
        -0.0022148876,
        0.0007324762,
        -0.043074775,
        -0.022286467,
        0.008625922,
        0.02142848,
        -0.0073909024,
        0.027421346,
        0.017900128,
        -0.023015697,
        -0.0061920052,
        -0.012165121,
        0.03620315,
        -0.0138395885,
        -0.028557424,
        0.03163363,
        0.012596874,
        0.00026685043,
        -0.032377686,
        -0.015110613,
        -0.04504055,
        -0.007568482,
        -0.01130051,
        -0.003450596,
        -0.029834794,
        -0.027013648,
        -0.0058175996,
        -0.0019192365,
        0.00041820318,
        0.0050838147,
        0.013726719,
        0.007036958,
        0.003545772,
        -0.009072308,
        -0.012706894,
        -0.036647767,
        -0.00082892174,
        0.026901677,
        -0.012633059,
        0.004610448,
        -0.005748125,
        0.035237033,
        -0.01499439,
        -0.005701777,
        0.0028357543,
        -0.0064077624,
        -0.006979315,
        0.0075500193,
        -0.021794721,
        0.0047982982,
        0.007196507,
        -0.0051551196,
        0.0047870725,
        -0.034963112,
        -0.010326103,
        -0.016458802,
        -0.0075736847,
        0.024930794,
        -0.012493719,
        0.01021366,
        0.025961043,
        -0.0053939824,
        -0.008699496,
        0.0064072227,
        -0.0054730517,
        0.033535995,
        0.025816264,
        -0.017004434,
        0.009664417,
        0.0035502182,
        0.006701562,
        -0.00738314,
        0.022223357,
        0.027099004,
        -0.017334715,
        -0.006474445,
        -0.0069762706,
        0.0021426124,
        0.007500741,
        -0.022108292,
        0.00023468338,
        -0.05546362,
        -0.006198404,
        -0.0014603651,
        0.0076991,
        -0.011965072,
        -0.0035243728,
        0.0066969576,
        -0.015409749,
        0.008023496,
        0.021568751,
        -0.020722529,
        -0.010793787,
        0.006219198,
        -0.021521414,
        0.019526742,
        0.006630582,
        -0.012894297,
        -0.014513174,
        -0.020962752,
        0.01726893,
        -0.0101520745,
        0.00020926908,
        0.036367223,
        -0.009511682,
        -0.0014615419,
        0.01009207,
        -0.020393662,
        -0.0047785966,
        -0.00872326,
        -0.013176512,
        0.0046647345,
        0.016558321,
        0.032436848,
        0.0077915285,
        0.017589226,
        -0.0027691075,
        -0.013967765,
        0.009581303,
        -0.0012659831,
        -0.0052935407,
        0.033838272,
        -0.026091643,
        -0.0016470912,
        0.018152341,
        -0.017131045,
        0.009668729,
        -0.0053922324,
        -0.011358787,
        -0.00989698,
        -0.012441324,
        -3.7370624e-5,
        -0.10047471,
        -0.0057811765,
        0.009315752,
        -0.020834174,
        -0.020974174,
        -0.0073830886,
        -0.008654819,
        -0.016337188,
        -0.00029812055,
        0.01707884,
        0.0053849984,
        0.0018781098,
        -0.004620419,
        -0.0107303895,
        0.00419624,
        0.023895182,
        -0.006934028,
        -0.010357231,
        0.009797996,
        -0.02170059,
        -0.025779959,
        -0.0070698448,
        0.018098904,
        -0.008830505,
        0.0055202325,
        0.00034947743,
        -0.001004431,
        -0.008568167,
        0.0012661318,
        0.021165118,
        -0.015183544,
        0.0052622845,
        -0.00077420444,
        0.03225901,
        0.007319332,
        0.0030907881,
        -0.0062336153,
        0.007079433,
        0.0004046266,
        0.016945718,
        0.0059209946,
        0.001869848,
        -0.008248839,
        -0.019615693,
        -0.0027785478,
        0.020561904,
        0.0101569295,
        0.00521305,
        0.019105554,
        -0.0086364,
        -0.019677332,
        -0.025349919,
        0.00063841743,
        -0.006347937,
        0.0121276565,
        -0.006602772,
        -0.026650455,
        0.02066325,
        -0.0217945,
        0.011445733,
        0.00882543,
        0.018347183,
        0.013674919,
        0.02442692,
        0.0046737334,
        -0.0010353575,
        0.005178403,
        0.03915081,
        0.0035562378,
        -0.008584357,
        -0.02107953,
        -0.01425769,
        0.009451288,
        -0.017853761,
        0.003446028,
        -0.0049852356,
        -0.017755901,
        0.010706867,
        0.010006356,
        0.009393552,
        -0.003678826,
        -0.0010849158,
        -0.06196726,
        -0.00091775303,
        -0.015870221,
        -0.011872269,
        0.01982744,
        0.0005714932,
        -0.012873662,
        -0.002059416,
        0.009688299,
        -0.0057105166,
        0.0075447634,
        0.015656956,
        -0.0042288047,
        -0.0120665515,
        -0.0047512325,
        0.006912609,
        -0.0032095946,
        0.033415504,
        0.017267609,
        -0.012810057,
        -0.022285054,
        -0.00737886,
        0.007371368,
        0.010447992,
        -0.023326928,
        0.017011812,
        -0.01643731,
        -0.011386002,
        0.0077034147,
        -0.016192576,
        0.03215395,
        -0.16293769,
        0.010571327,
        0.0003281214,
        -0.0033666722,
        -0.0056777317,
        -0.0033832735,
        0.012895317,
        -0.0042177625,
        -0.0059874617,
        -0.009324114,
        0.009055457,
        -0.012444348,
        -0.019916177,
        0.008753272,
        0.02867659,
        0.11177753,
        -0.015663924,
        0.013238512,
        0.0034215515,
        -0.020465918,
        0.0060073184,
        0.008654555,
        0.013235812,
        -0.012333462,
        -0.0045981263,
        0.021494508,
        -0.0010858614,
        0.000313601,
        -0.0064558745,
        0.031793855,
        0.0084074875,
        0.021819048,
        -0.0249944,
        0.009311599,
        0.014641566,
        -0.0068274816,
        -0.0013562188,
        0.007476972,
        0.037282806,
        -0.0131711075,
        0.0059053986,
        -0.031939358,
        -0.005096621,
        -0.003062632,
        -0.003997652,
        -0.009980732,
        -0.0314943,
        -0.0048816707,
        -0.029523274,
        0.0051422943,
        -0.033792567,
        -0.08744255,
        0.015405075,
        -0.003279625,
        0.009630117,
        -0.0009747777,
        -0.014343912,
        0.039109603,
        0.013198746,
        0.0021931503,
        -0.010636817,
        0.011037401,
        0.030765064,
        0.010455313,
        -0.0002728347,
        0.008917646,
        0.019265452,
        0.0173804,
        -0.012300536,
        -0.0030271073,
        -0.00049487926,
        0.011992175,
        -0.022135483,
        0.0025803861,
        -0.033367194,
        0.008295351,
        -0.03962781,
        -0.0025052554,
        0.014016719,
        -0.0047948672,
        0.00924381,
        0.008388545,
        0.0165777,
        0.021864882,
        0.0053723133,
        -0.022537887,
        -0.018767145,
        -0.009481229,
        -0.020705491,
        0.016769428,
        -0.000548683,
        0.017005088,
        -0.01208501,
        -0.008825688,
        -0.0038274417,
        0.00661828,
        0.0023015356,
        0.0036100368,
        -0.011614151,
        0.03320414,
        -0.034370013,
        0.006456156,
        -0.0037556116,
        -0.03509722,
        0.008702767,
        -0.011216193,
        0.024061518,
        -0.0056286226,
        0.05181449,
        -0.018222092
    ],
    "ai_confidence_score": 0.9999999999999999,
    "ai_extraction_metadata": {
        "extracted_at": "2026-02-20T01:16:31.394638Z",
        "ai_model": "gemini-2.0-flash-lite",
        "extraction_method": "automated",
        "content_length": 6783,
        "url": "https:\/\/nytimes.com\/2026\/02\/16\/nyregion\/columbia-epstein-dental-shuliak.html",
        "existing_metadata": {
            "author_name": null,
            "published_at": null,
            "domain_name": null,
            "site_name": null,
            "section": null,
            "publisher": null
        }
    }
}

{
    "extracted_at": "2026-02-20T01:16:31.394638Z",
    "ai_model": "gemini-2.0-flash-lite",
    "extraction_method": "automated",
    "content_length": 6783,
    "url": "https:\/\/nytimes.com\/2026\/02\/16\/nyregion\/columbia-epstein-dental-shuliak.html",
    "existing_metadata": {
        "author_name": null,
        "published_at": null,
        "domain_name": null,
        "site_name": null,
        "section": null,
        "publisher": null
    }
}