View detailed information about this source submission and its extracted claims.
Over 85 scientists criticized a Trump administration report downplaying climate change, citing errors and misrepresentations. The report was used to justify repealing emission limits, prompting a strong rebuttal.
Automatically extracted metadata and content analysis.
{ "tone": "informative", "perspective": "neutral", "audience": "general", "credibility_indicators": [ "expert_quotes", "data_cited", "multiple_sources" ] }
Complete details about this source submission.
{ "source_type": "extension", "content_hash": "a2b237dc18d2d4a95f6277e3008d9db07eb8b5140747e3e4742c4e9c9b080cb5", "submitted_via": "chrome_extension", "extension_version": "1.0.18", "claim_extraction_result_summary": { "total_processed": 16, "attached": 0, "detached": 0, "updated": 16, "target_claim_uuids": [ "9fc89594-e959-40c6-aee1-830e2b3ecf5a", "9fc89595-d681-4750-a835-397f2781cc5d", "9fc89596-c063-442e-9317-fa3cb289c336", "9fc89597-b91c-4f9d-b229-5f6b4f40e0a7", "9fc89598-c055-4051-a69d-2d1130e9c395", "9fc89599-a9dc-40fb-9438-23fd8e003962", "9fc8959a-b0de-48af-bdc3-4cb7e5abb186", "9fc8959b-b2a7-4961-ab40-7a3ec780053b", "9fc8959c-a5fb-41a0-a0bc-b7338a60d5a2", "9fc8959d-98bf-4626-9b73-e487dc940c98", "9fc8959e-8aab-48b6-822a-0f90b8e69660", "9fc8959f-8c8e-474c-9c10-bfe00a640b6d", "9fc895a0-8ad5-43d8-a596-0a1ceec2ffb8", "9fc895a1-7cbc-489c-95fc-09cd4d2057db", "9fc895a2-6bd8-44bd-ae27-e5384565689d", "9fc895a3-5dad-492a-b8ec-57d3b33c9ff2" ], "updated_at": "2025-09-02T18:47:07.236165Z" }, "claim_extraction_result": { "total_claims": 16, "similar_claims_found": 0, "new_claims_created": 16, "processed_claims": [ { "uuid": "9fc89594-e959-40c6-aee1-830e2b3ecf5a", "text": "More than 85 American and international scientists have condemned a Trump administration report that calls the threat of climate change overblown, saying the analysis is riddled with errors, misrepresentations and cherry-picked data to fit the president\u2019s political agenda.", "simplified_text": "More than 85 scientists condemned Trump administration report calling climate change threat overblown riddled with errors misrepresentations cherry-picked data.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Climate Change", "Politics", "Science" ], "confidence": 0.9, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null }, { "uuid": "9fc89595-d681-4750-a835-397f2781cc5d", "text": "The scientists submitted their critique as part of a public comment period on the report, which was to close Tuesday night.", "simplified_text": "Scientists submitted critique during public comment period closing Tuesday night.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Science", "Government" ], "confidence": 1, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null }, { "uuid": "9fc89596-c063-442e-9317-fa3cb289c336", "text": "\u201cNo one should doubt that human-caused climate change is real, is already producing potentially dangerous impacts, and that humanity is on track for a geologically enormous amount of warming,\u201d the scientists wrote.", "simplified_text": "Scientists wrote human-caused climate change is real producing dangerous impacts humanity is on track for enormous warming.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Climate Change", "Science" ], "confidence": 1, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null }, { "uuid": "9fc89597-b91c-4f9d-b229-5f6b4f40e0a7", "text": "The five researchers who prepared the administration\u2019s July report were handpicked by Chris Wright, the energy secretary, and they all reject the established scientific consensus that the burning of oil, gas and coal is dangerously heating the planet.", "simplified_text": "Five researchers preparing administration's July report were handpicked by Chris Wright all reject scientific consensus burning oil gas coal is dangerously heating planet.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Politics", "Science", "Energy" ], "confidence": 0.9, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null }, { "uuid": "9fc89598-c055-4051-a69d-2d1130e9c395", "text": "They acknowledged that the Earth is warming but said that climate change is \u201cless damaging economically than commonly believed.\u201d", "simplified_text": "Researchers acknowledged Earth is warming but said climate change is less damaging economically than commonly believed.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Climate Change", "Economics" ], "confidence": 0.8, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null }, { "uuid": "9fc89599-a9dc-40fb-9438-23fd8e003962", "text": "The administration used the report to justify its recent announcement that it would repeal limits on greenhouse gas emissions that stem from burning fossil fuels.", "simplified_text": "Administration used report to justify repealing limits on greenhouse gas emissions from burning fossil fuels.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Politics", "Environment", "Energy" ], "confidence": 0.9, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null }, { "uuid": "9fc8959a-b0de-48af-bdc3-4cb7e5abb186", "text": "At the same time, average global temperatures have risen by between 1.25 and 1.41 degrees Celsius (or 2.25 to 2.53 degrees Fahrenheit), compared with preindustrial times.", "simplified_text": "Average global temperatures have risen between 1.25 and 1.41 degrees Celsius compared with preindustrial times.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Climate Change", "Science" ], "confidence": 1, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null }, { "uuid": "9fc8959b-b2a7-4961-ab40-7a3ec780053b", "text": "That may sound small, but the warming has impacted every region of the planet with more frequent and intense heat waves, floods, wildfires, droughts and other disasters.", "simplified_text": "Warming has impacted every region with more frequent intense heat waves floods wildfires droughts disasters.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Climate Change", "Environment" ], "confidence": 0.9, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null }, { "uuid": "9fc8959c-a5fb-41a0-a0bc-b7338a60d5a2", "text": "Already the Environmental Protection Agency is using the Energy Department analysis to justify the repeal of the endangerment finding, a 2009 scientific declaration that climate change poses a danger to human health and welfare.", "simplified_text": "EPA is using Energy Department analysis to justify repeal of endangerment finding climate change poses danger to human health welfare.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Politics", "Environment", "Health", "Regulatory" ], "confidence": 0.9, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null }, { "uuid": "9fc8959d-98bf-4626-9b73-e487dc940c98", "text": "That finding is the basis for regulations of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gas emissions from such sources as automobiles and power plants.", "simplified_text": "Endangerment finding is basis for regulations of carbon dioxide greenhouse gas emissions from automobiles power plants.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Environment", "Regulatory" ], "confidence": 1, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null }, { "uuid": "9fc8959e-8aab-48b6-822a-0f90b8e69660", "text": "By Tuesday morning, more than 2,300 comments had been filed regarding the report.", "simplified_text": "More than 2300 comments had been filed regarding the report by Tuesday morning.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Government", "Science" ], "confidence": 1, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null }, { "uuid": "9fc8959f-8c8e-474c-9c10-bfe00a640b6d", "text": "Among them was a submission from the American Meteorological Society, a premier climate science organization, which outlined what it called \u201cfoundational flaws\u201d in the report and called on the government to correct the findings.", "simplified_text": "American Meteorological Society outlined foundational flaws in report called on government to correct findings.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Science", "Government" ], "confidence": 0.9, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null }, { "uuid": "9fc895a0-8ad5-43d8-a596-0a1ceec2ffb8", "text": "The Energy Department report states that carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas that helps plants grow, and therefore more gas would improve agricultural yields.", "simplified_text": "Energy Department report states carbon dioxide is greenhouse gas helps plants grow more gas would improve agricultural yields.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Science", "Environment", "Agriculture" ], "confidence": 0.8, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null }, { "uuid": "9fc895a1-7cbc-489c-95fc-09cd4d2057db", "text": "In another instance, the Trump administration\u2019s report cited two studies by Antonio Gasparrini, a professor of epidemiology at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, to support its statement that deaths caused by cold weather exceed those caused by heat.", "simplified_text": "Trump administration's report cited studies by Antonio Gasparrini to support statement deaths caused by cold weather exceed those caused by heat.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Science", "Health" ], "confidence": 0.9, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null }, { "uuid": "9fc895a2-6bd8-44bd-ae27-e5384565689d", "text": "While that is true, Dr. Gasparrini said, the report ignores the fact that climate change is increasing heat-related deaths, and at a greater rate than it would prevent deaths from cold.", "simplified_text": "Dr Gasparrini said report ignores climate change is increasing heat-related deaths at greater rate than preventing cold deaths.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Science", "Health" ], "confidence": 0.9, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null }, { "uuid": "9fc895a3-5dad-492a-b8ec-57d3b33c9ff2", "text": "At the same time, average global temperatures have risen by between 1.25 and 1.41 degrees Celsius (or 2.25 to 2.53 degrees Fahrenheit), compared with preindustrial times.", "simplified_text": "Average global temperatures have risen between 1.25 and 1.41 degrees Celsius compared with preindustrial times.", "claim_maker": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "claim_subject_tags": [ "Climate Change", "Science" ], "confidence": 1, "context_type": "News Article", "similarity_found": false, "linked_to": null, "similarity_score": null } ], "improved_author": "Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey", "suggested_reeval_at": "2026-09-02 18:41:36" } }
{ "extracted_at": "2025-09-02T18:39:22.067352Z", "ai_model": "gemini-1.5-flash", "extraction_method": "automated", "content_length": 8808, "url": "https:\/\/www.nytimes.com\/2025\/09\/02\/climate\/climate-science-report-energy-department.html?campaign_id=60&emc=edit_na_20250902&instance_id=161747&nl=breaking-news®i_id=122976029&segment_id=205119&user_id=b25c5730c89e0c73f75709d8f1254337", "existing_metadata": { "author_name": null, "published_at": null, "domain_name": null, "site_name": null, "section": null, "publisher": null } }
<html lang="en" class="story nytapp-vi-article nytapp-vi-story story nytapp-vi-article " data-nyt-compute-assignment="fallback" xmlns:og="http://opengraphprotocol.org/schema/" data-rh="lang,class"><head> <meta charset="utf-8"> <title>Scientists Denounce Trump Administration’s Climate Report - The New York Times</title> <meta data-rh="true" name="robots" content="noarchive, max-image-preview:large"><meta data-rh="true" name="description" content="Scores of researchers reviewed the Energy Department’s argument about greenhouse gases and found serious deficiencies."><meta data-rh="true" property="twitter:url" content="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/02/climate/climate-science-report-energy-department.html"><meta data-rh="true" property="twitter:title" content="Scientists Denounce Trump Administration’s Climate Report"><meta data-rh="true" property="twitter:description" content="Scores of researchers reviewed the Energy Department’s argument about greenhouse gases and...
Scientists Denounce Trump Administration’s Climate Report By Lisa Friedman and Sachi Kitajima Mulkey Sept. 2, 2025Updated 1:42 p.m. ET More than 85 American and international scientists have condemned a Trump administration report that calls the threat of climate change overblown, saying the analysis is riddled with errors, misrepresentations and cherry-picked data to fit the president’s political agenda. The scientists submitted their critique as part of a public comment period on the report, which was to close Tuesday night. “No one should doubt that human-caused climate change is real, is already producing potentially dangerous impacts, and that humanity is on track for a geologically enormous amount of warming,” the scientists wrote. They compared the administration’s report to efforts by the tobacco industry to create doubt around the health links between smoking and cancer. The five researchers who prepared the administration’s July report were handpicked by Chris Wright, t...
Detailed status of each processing step.
All claims extracted from this source document.